Card values / Hockey / Matthew Schaefer

2025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 Matthew Schaefer #451 Young Guns

Recent sales across marketplaces, recomputed daily. Raw and graded shown separately. Updated November 14, 2026.

Raw, last 30 days

$169

0 sales

PSA 10

$903

2 sales

90-day trend

-6%

raw median, recent vs prior

Liquidity

Low

0.22 sales a day

What this card sells for

A raw 2025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 #451 Matthew Schaefer Young Guns sold for a median of $169 across marketplaces, based on 16 sales. PSA 10 copies sold for a median of $903, $733 more than raw. The raw median is down 6% over the last 90 days.

20 sales from the last 90 days are used and 2 are excluded (lots, reprints, damaged copies and outliers). The card sells about 0.22 times a day, so liquidity is low. After eBay fees and envelope shipping, a raw copy at the median nets about $145.25.

Raw price, weekly median

$136$165$194 Aug 24 Sep 28

Recent sales behind the number

DateListingGradeSoldUsed
2026-10-03 2025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 Young Guns Matthew Schaefer #451 Rookie RC Raw $147.59 Included
2026-10-03 2025-26 Matthew Schaefer Young Guns Upper Deck Series 2 Hockey #451 Raw $165.00 Included
2026-10-03 2025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 Young Guns Matthew Schaefer #451 Rookie RC Raw $200.00 Included
2026-10-02 2025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 Matthew Schaefer Young Guns RC #451 NY Islanders Raw $168.33 Included
2026-09-30 2025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 - Young Guns Matthew Schaefer PSA 10 #451 (RC) PSA 10 $825.00 Included
2026-09-30 2025-26 UD Series 2 Matthew Schaefer Young Guns PSA 9 #451 RC Islanders PSA 9 $230.00 Included
2026-09-30 UPPER DECK 2025-26 SERIES 2 YOUNG GUNS MATTHEW SCHAEFER #451 RC PSA 9 PSA 9 $203.50 Included
2026-09-30 Upper Deck 2025-26 Series 2 Young Guns Matthew Schaefer #451 Rookie Islanders Raw $135.00 Included
2026-09-29 2025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 - Young Guns Matthew Schaefer #451 Oversized (RC) Raw $40.00 Excluded: price outlier
2026-09-06 2025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 Young Guns Matthew Schaefer #451 Rookie RC Raw $160.00 Included

20 sales used, 2 excluded, from the last 90 days. Showing the 10 most recent.

By grade

Raw

$169

16 sales

PSA 9

$217

2 sales

PSA 10

$903

2 sales

Grading gap

+$733

PSA 10 over raw. Run the numbers

More card values

All card values

Questions people ask

How much is a 2025-26 Upper Deck Series 2 #451 Matthew Schaefer Young Guns worth?
Raw copies sold for a median of $169 in the last 90 days across marketplaces, from 16 sales. PSA 10 copies sold for a median of $903.
Is the Matthew Schaefer Young Guns worth grading?
A PSA 10 sells for about $733 more than a raw copy right now. Grading runs about $25 and 30 to 45 days, so it pays when the card is clean.
Where do these prices come from?
Completed sales across marketplaces from the last 90 days, recomputed daily. Lots, sealed product, reprints, damaged copies and price outliers are excluded and shown as excluded in the recent sales list. Last updated November 14, 2026.

Put your store on autopilot.

Scan a card, get a price from real sold comps, publish to eBay in one click. Your first 7 days or 200 scans are free.

Start your 7-day free trial

No credit card required. Founding pricing is limited to ten subscribers: $19.95/mo for life.